Today online brokerage E*Trade lost over 50% of the stock value after an analyst at Citibank cited potential losses from sub-prime mortgages that the company might not be able to recover from.
You know, this sounds awful speculative to me. Even on Fast Money they are backing Ameritrade(AMTD) over E*Trade(ETFC) as if AMTD is doing better because of the problems at ETFC. They also think investors are going to be leaving E*Trade in droves over fear they might not get their money back.
All this maybe, might not, could be, possibly…blah blah blah. It’s all noise. What I see here is a huge sale on a stock that I have had an account with since 1997. As a multi billion dollar company, you don’t survive 10 years in such a competitive environment without having diversified your business model. The facts are, yes they had some mortgage backed securities that melted down just like everyone else. Just like Bear-Stearns, Goldman Sachs, Schwabb, you name it…every single one of the financial companies trading made bad decisions into the low rate mortgage market.
But E*Trade isn’t just a bank. They are a brokerage like Ameritrade. E*Trade’s brokerage business is fine and the fundamentals are intact. Now I have been holding Ameritrade shares since December 2005 and the performance of that stock has been less than stellar. A special dividend caused investors to bolt from the stock after they received the dividend and it has had trouble ever since. At the time, Ameritrade was at $26 so it’s still $6 below that high. I still hold shares of AMTD but I also pulled the trigger (50 shares) on E*Trade because the upside looks too good.
E*Trade will recover from their mortgage woes and their growth is going to continue. I’ll ride out this storm and after I think will book a solid gain in a very short time. E*Trade as everyone has been saying is now even more of a takeover target than it had been. According to news posted by the brokerage, they still have over a billion in capitalization and aren’t worried about the issues mentioned in the press today. They also stated the remarks by Citibank were irresponsible and inaccurate.
My take? Take a small position you can live with because I think you get an easy double on E*Trade. 200 million shares traded hands today so even if there are shorts they are going to have to cover quickly on that kind of volume.